Monday, March 15, 2010

RENDITION - a Forum - and a Missing (Irish) Speaker

For more info on Rendition/Extraordinary Renditions and upcoming Forum "Weaving a Net of Accountability" at Duke University North Carolina April 8-10, please go to ncstoptorturenow dot org LINK HERE

NOTE that usually this kind of stark report with data will be now be posted at
nomorecrusades dot blogspot cot com - HERE (rather than here at oneheartforpeace dot blogspot dot com) for a longer version, plz go there.

The only significant edit by the News & Observer article below was the removal of this sentence about Binyam Mohamed’s treatment in Morocco :

“His genitals were slashed and doused in a hot, stinging liquid.”


Following article published Mon, Mar 15, 2010 02:00 AM -
Modified Mon, Mar 15, 2010 06:01 AM

Extraordinary rendition and a missing speaker
(the News & Observer - North Carolina - USA)

This is a time of year when many Americans celebrate their Irish roots.

But the U.S. government doesn't want North Carolinians getting too close to at least one Irishman.

In the past, this would have been someone like Gerry Adams, the politician with ties to the Irish Republican Army. But Edward Horgan is no rebel; he was an officer in the Irish Defence Forces for 22 years. He served as a United Nations peacekeeper in Cyprus and the Sinai. Currently, he monitors elections in places like Ghana, Armenia , Zimbabwe , East Timor and Ukraine .

Last year, Horgan visited the United States to see family and attend the presidential inauguration. But this year, while observing elections in frigid Kiev, he learned that his 10-year, multiple-entry U.S. visa had been revoked.

The reason? No official will say, though Horgan is scheduled to attend an April conference at Duke University to speak about his opposition to extraordinary rendition.

Horgan co-founded Shannon Watch, a grass-roots group that protests the use of Ireland 's main international airport as a stop for U.S. planes transporting terror suspects to secret sites. Human rights groups report that dozens of detainees have been tortured. Others have "disappeared," vanished without a trace.

In 2002, Binyam Mohamed was a legal resident of the U.K. when he was detained and tortured by U.S., British and Pakistani authorities in Pakistan. He was then "rendered" to Morocco, where he endured 18 months of truly medieval abuse - at the hands of the Moroccans, but at the behest of the Central Intelligence Agency. He was allegedly beaten severely and threatened with electrocution, rape and execution.

In 2004, Mohamed was rendered again, this time to Afghanistan. In the infamous "Dark Prison," he was held in almost complete darkness for 23 hours a day, and kept awake for days at a time with loud music and spooky recordings. He was then flown to Guantanamo. After four years, he was released without any charge - or a single day in court.

North Carolinians need to know that the pilots and crews that twice transported Mohamed are based in North Carolina. Many credible reports indicate that Smithfield-based Aero Contractors - working for the CIA - picks up detainees and flies them to sites where torture is commonplace. After making the Atlantic crossing, planes often refuel at Shannon, where Irish citizens like Horgan voice their non-violent protest of a serious human rights abuse.

Horgan has exercised his right to protest at Shannon for nearly a decade. What changed since he visited the U.S. as a tourist last year? Visa holders have undergone intense scrutiny since the attempted Christmas bombing. But this is quite another case. Does Washington want to shield us from prominent critics of extraordinary rendition?

That would be a daunting task, since the number of critics is growing. A 2007 Council of Europe report said the CIA operated secret prisons in Europe where terrorism suspects were interrogated and tortured. That same year, a German judge issued warrants for CIA agents and contractors, including three North Carolina-based pilots. Last year, an Italian judge convicted a CIA chief and 22 other Americans, almost all CIA operatives, of kidnapping a Muslim cleric from Milan in 2003.

Two days after his inauguration, President Barack Obama took the overdue step of banning torture by U.S. officials, moving us away from the "dark side" advocated by our former vice president, Dick Cheney. Since then, however, Obama's record has been mixed.

Extraordinary rendition continues, with North Carolina as a likely hub. The Department of Justice continues to block torture survivors' civil lawsuits, arguing that a hearing would jeopardize state secrets - despite the fact that these are well-known international scandals.

At a minimum, we need to stop kidnapping people, holding them in secret prisons and torturing them. We won't move past this shameful legacy by muzzling critics or denying torture survivors a day in court. As Horgan says, he and many people around the world still look up to the United States as a symbol of freedom and the rule of law.

What many do not know about St. Patrick is that he was born in Britain and originally came to Ireland a slave. He escaped, but later had a vision that the Irish needed him, so returned. He fought to free other slaves before dying a revered old man near modern-day Belfast.

We have nothing to fear from critics like Horgan. To the contrary, such voices should be welcomed, since they may help us find our way back from the dark side.

Christina Cowger works with North Carolina Stop Torture Now. Robin Kirk directs the Duke Human Rights Center. Information about the April 8-10 conference is at accountabilityfortorturenc dot org

Orignal publication News & Observer dot com - GO HERE


The following includes Retd. Commandant Edward J. Horgan's Curriculum Vitae at statewatch dot org (all worth reading) still available as of March 15, 2010: 1 CURRICULUM VITAE Edward J. Horgan Commandant (retd.) File Format: PDF/Adobe Acrobat -Quick View Charnwood, Newtown, Castletroy, Co. Limerick. Telephone: 061-330567 Mobile Phone 085-1026631. Email:, HERE

By Edward J. Horgan (the following found on the above linked Curriculum Vitae)

My efforts to promote peace by peaceful means include:
• Organise peaceful demonstrations against the abuse of Irish neutrality arising from US military use at Shannon airport for unlawful wars in Afghanistan and Iraq from 2001 to date.
• Initiating a peace camp at Shannon airport in January 2001 to create public awareness of Ireland’s breach of the Hague Convention on Neutrality.
• Took High Court Constitutional case against Irish Government over the Shannon issue
in March 2003
• Returned all my military and UN decorations and Presidential Commissioning
Certificate in Sept 2003, in protest at the Irish Government’s participation in the Iraq.
• Unjustly and unlawfully arrested or detained during protests or while simply transiting through Shannon airport on four occasions, since 2002.

My efforts to promote peace and justice, by peaceful means and the rule of law will continue.

REPORT from Sunday's vigil (yesterday) on Irish Mother's Day HERE
On Sunday March 14th, a group of peaceful demonstrators gathered at Shannon to mark the seventh anniversary of the US-led invasion of Iraq, and to relaunch the Black Shamrock simultaneously with DAWC/FEIC in Derry.

VIDEO HERE SCOTT HORTON on Renditions under Obama (continuing Renditions policy Under Bush) From August 14, 2009 (which would lead many casual observers to ask: what else did Raymond Azar know?)

Renditions Buffoonery—By Scott Horton (Harper's Magazine) In a breathless piece of reporting in the Sunday Los Angeles Times, we are told that Barack Obama “left intact”...HERE

Renditions, Obama Style—By Scott Horton (Harper's Magazine) By Scott Horton. Raymond Azar is a 45-year-old Lebanese construction manager who traveled to Kabul in April to meet with one of his HERE

More from Scott Horton:

RECENT: Lawfare Redux HERE (SEE how internationally concerned Lawyers vouch for Pakistani lawyers' work toward the Rule of Law)

Obama and the Torture Hangover (What's happening since Obama to the Geneva Conventions and International Law HERE



Connie L. Nash said...

3/15, Spencer Ackerman, Washington Independent, More McCarthyism From Liz Cheney's Crew

3/15, Emptywheel, The Torture Apologists Ratchet Up the Attack

3/15, Glenn Greenwald, Salon, Salon Radio: Manipulative use of the term "Terrorism"

3/15, Eric Lichtblau, New York Times, Report Faults U.S.'s Efforts at Transparency

3/15, Eugene R Fidell, Politico, Why New York's the right place to try Sept. 11 cases

3/14, Agence France-Presse, Justice Department witchhunt backfires in US

3/14, Andy Worthington, TruthOut, What Torture Is and Why It's Illegal and Not "Poor Judgement"

all above at Bill of Rights Defense Committee bordc dot org

Connie L. Nash said...

Addional NC Resources toward ending torture and renditions:

Connie L. Nash said...

From Chuck Fager of Quaker House fame:

Not going to Washington this weekend? Still want to mark the seventh anniversary of the Iraq invasion?

Join us in Fayetteville for a peace vigil and rally at the Market House downtown, 1-4 pm

Great Weather for a Peace Vigil/Rally!

Yes! The forecast for Fayetteville March 20 is for mostly sunny with a high of 69 degrees. Perfect conditions for a peace rally.**

Come join us -- and Spread the Word

**Besides, even if it did rain, the Market House has a covered atrium where we could carry on, snug and dry. So we're on, rain or shine.

There's more about this vigil/rally at our blog:

And on our Facebook page:!/event.php?eid=335219957819&ref=ts

Connie L. Nash said...

There have been INNUMERABLE crazy comments with no relative value at all coming in for this particular post???

What is the point? To draw attention to this post or to think that such harassment might hide some truth?

Anonymous said...

It's all a trap, but it's one that goes worse when a helicopter is shown on the scene and everything gets broadcast to the world.